《晋书·刑法志》中记载了关于肉刑存废的大讨论。肉刑产生的历史背景以及社会发展两个方面的原因决定了肉刑废除的必然性。而已被废除的肉刑重新引起争端的原因则是由于肉刑废除后刑罚结构存在较大问题以及法家思想重新得到重视引起的。死刑的废除一直是法学界争论不休的问题,这几千年前发生的大讨论也可以为如今死刑存废提供一些启示,唯有寻找到适当的替代刑并巩固群众基础才能为死刑的废除铺平道路。
Criminal Law of Jinshu present several hot debates about the existence or abolishment of the Corporal punishement.Its historical background as well as the progress of the society determined that the Corporal punishment is bound to be abolished. Because of the imperfection system of punishment and the Legalists thoughts' renaissance,the abolished punishment caused debate once again.The abolishment of Death penalty cause a long time discussion in the jurisprudential circle.The hot debate happened thousand years ago gives useful enlightenment for the abolition of the Death penalty contemporarily.Only if we find the appropriate punishment and gain a solid mass base,can we smooth out the road to abolish the Death penalty.