位置:成果数据库 > 期刊 > 期刊详情页
基于AGREEⅡ工具的高血压病中医临床实践指南评价
  • ISSN号:1673-1727
  • 期刊名称:《中华中医药杂志》
  • 分类:R4[医药卫生—临床医学]
  • 作者机构:[1]中国中医科学院中医临床基础医学研究所,北京100700, [2]中国中医科学院西苑医院,北京100091
  • 相关基金:国家自然科学基金项目(No.81202846),中国中医科学院自主选题资助项目(No.Z0260)
中文摘要:

目的:采用AGREEⅡ工具评价我国已经发布的高血压病中医临床实践指南的质量。方法:采用手工检索与网络检索相结合的方法,检索国内已经公开发布的高血压病中医临床实践指南。采用AGREEⅡ工具进行评价,每个指南由3名评价者进行评价。分别分析每个指南的范围与目的、参与人员、制定的严谨性、清晰性与可读性、应用性、编辑独立性,最后进行指南的全面评估。结果:共纳入6个指南,评价结果表明,高血压病中医临床实践指南的清晰性与可读性质量最高,平均得分为60.2%;其次为编辑的独立性,平均得分52.9%;参与人员平均得分50.O%;制定的严谨性平均得分47.1%;范围和目的平均得分42.6%;应用性质量最低,平均得分37.8%。全面评估显示,强烈推荐使用的指南有2个,推荐(补充或改进)的指南有2个,2个指南不能确定是否推荐使用。结论:高血压病中医临床实践指南的应用性很低,在以后的指南研制中,要注重指南应用性质量的提高。

英文摘要:

Objective: Using AGREE H instrument to evaluate the quality of the hypertensive TCM clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) which has been released in China. Methods: Using the method of manual search and network retrieval, search the hypertension TCM clinical practice guideline that has been published in China. The CPGs assessed by AGREE II instrument were included. Data in each CPG were analyzed in terms of six domains in the AGREE 1I instrument including scope and purpose, participants, conscientiousness, clarity, readability, applicability and editorial independence of CPGs. Results: There are 6 CPGs identified. All of the CPGs were included. The results showed that the quality of the clarity and readability was highest of all the CPGs. The average score was 60.2%. The editorial independence of CPGs was also good. The average score was 52.9%. The participants scored 50.0%. The conscientiousness of CPGs development scored 47.1%. The scope and purpose scored 42.6%. The applicability scored the lowest with only 37.8%. The general evaluation revealed that two CPGs were rated as 'strongly recommended', two as 'recommended with provision or aitemation', and two as 'unsure'. Conclusion: The quality of applicability is a significant shortcoming. Special attention should be paid to improve the quality of applicability in the development of hypertension TCM CPGs.

同期刊论文项目
同项目期刊论文
期刊信息
  • 《中华中医药杂志》
  • 中国科技核心期刊
  • 主管单位:中国科学技术协会
  • 主办单位:中国中医药学会
  • 主编:佘倩
  • 地址:北京市和平街北口樱花路甲4号
  • 邮编:100029
  • 邮箱:
  • 电话:
  • 国际标准刊号:ISSN:1673-1727
  • 国内统一刊号:ISSN:11-5334/R
  • 邮发代号:18-90
  • 获奖情况:
  • 国家中医药管理局优秀期刊一等奖
  • 国内外数据库收录:
  • 美国化学文摘(网络版),英国农业与生物科学研究中心文摘,波兰哥白尼索引,美国剑桥科学文摘,日本日本科学技术振兴机构数据库,中国中国科技核心期刊,中国北大核心期刊(2008版),中国北大核心期刊(2011版),中国北大核心期刊(2014版)
  • 被引量:36061