张惠言批点《山中白云词》,是在《词选》刊刻之后,批语主要分为编年、品评、探意三类,与《词选》的批评思路相一致。手批本更好地证明了董士锡论词时对于张炎的表彰和董毅在《续词选》中对于张炎的偏爱,这与张惠言的词学观念一脉相承。
Zhang Huiyan made the hand -written notes on Shan Zhong Bai Yun Ci after the publishing of Ci Xuan. These notes can be categorized into three types : chronological notes, notes to judge the artistic value and notes to explain the meanings. These notes are consistent with the critical methodologies of Ci Xuan. The existence of the book with hand - written notes can better prove Dong Shixi' s high praise for Zhang Yan when commenting on the Ci Poetry, as well as Dong Yi' s preference for Zhang Yan in Xu Ci Xuan.