位置:成果数据库 > 期刊 > 期刊详情页
儒家性朴论.以孔子、荀子、董仲舒为中心
  • ISSN号:0257-5833
  • 期刊名称:《社会科学》
  • 时间:0
  • 分类:B222[哲学宗教—中国哲学]
  • 作者机构:[1]华南师范大学政治与行政学院
  • 相关基金:本文系国家社科基金项目“苟学新探:以性朴论为中心”(项目编号:13BZX043)的阶段性成果.
作者: 周炽成[1]
中文摘要:

在儒家中持性朴论的典型代表是荀子和董仲舒,孔子也倾向于此论。《荀子》一书中的《礼论》、《劝学》、《荣辱》、《儒效》等都表明了人性朴,而《性恶》应该是荀子后学所作。董仲舒在继承荀子性朴论的基础上凸显了性中善的潜质,但不认可孟子的性善论。根据性朴论,人性不能说是善的,也不能说是恶的,而是中性的,故它不同于性善论,也不同于性恶论。性朴论也异于性有善有恶论和性无善无恶论。司马迁、董仲舒、韩婴等西汉中期的人未读过《性恶》,对我们推断它的产生时间很有帮助。

英文摘要:

Xunzi and Dong Zhongshu are typical representatives of Confucians who hold that man'soriginal natue is simple and uncarved. Confucius' opinion of human nature is similar to that. TheChapters in the Xunzi such as "Discourse on Ritural Principles", "Exhortation to Learning", "Of Honorand Disgrace", "the Teachings of Ru" show simple and uncarved human nature. The chapter "Man'sNature is Evil" should be written by Xunzi's followers, not by himself. Following Xunzi's opinion ofhuman nature, Dong Zhongshu highlighted the good potential of man's original nature. But he did notapprove of Mencius's doctrine of man's originalnature as fully good. According to the doctrine of man'soriginal nature as simple and uncarved, the nature is neither fully good nor fully evil, but basicallyneutral. It is different from both the doctrine that human nature is good and the doctrine that humannature is evil. Meanwhile, it doesn't mean that man's original nature is partly good and partly evil or thatthere is neither good or evil potentials in the nature. The fact that people in the middle Western HanDynasty such as Sima qian, Dong Zhongshu, Han Ying never read the chapter "Man's Nature is Evil" isvery helpful for us to detect the time when the chapter was written.

同期刊论文项目
同项目期刊论文
期刊信息
  • 《社会科学》
  • 北大核心期刊(2011版)
  • 主管单位:上海社会科学院
  • 主办单位:上海社会科学院
  • 主编:薛立勇
  • 地址:上海市淮海中路622弄7号337室
  • 邮编:200020
  • 邮箱:Hfl@sass.org.cn
  • 电话:021-33165518
  • 国际标准刊号:ISSN:0257-5833
  • 国内统一刊号:ISSN:31-1112
  • 邮发代号:4-273
  • 获奖情况:
  • 上海市第六届哲这社会科学优秀成果奖一等奖、三等奖,上海市第四届邓小平理论研究和宣传优秀成果奖
  • 国内外数据库收录:
  • 中国中国人文社科核心期刊,中国北大核心期刊(2004版),中国北大核心期刊(2008版),中国北大核心期刊(2011版),中国北大核心期刊(2014版),中国社科基金资助期刊,中国国家哲学社会科学学术期刊数据库,中国北大核心期刊(2000版)
  • 被引量:20678